The Heron and the Crab: a gentle retelling, the moral and questions
A hungry old heron tells the fish a frightening story, and one brave crab decides to see the truth for himself. This guide retells the Panchatantra tale for children aged five to nine, explains the moral and offers questions to talk about together.
Read it with pictures and colour it: the illustrated episode, with a free colouring page.
The story, retold
Once upon a time, an old heron lived beside a pond full of fish. He had grown too slow to catch them, and he was always hungry.
So the heron made a plan. He stood very still on the bank with his head hanging low, looking as sad as he could. A crab who lived in the pond came up to him. “What is wrong, Uncle Heron?” asked the crab.
“Terrible news,” sighed the heron. “There will be no rain this year. This pond will dry up, and all of you will be stuck in the mud.”
The fish heard him and were frightened. “Please help us!” they cried. The heron pretended to think. “I know a big lake beyond the hill,” he said. “It never dries up. I can carry you there, one at a time.”
Every day the heron flew off with a fish in his beak. But he did not take them to any lake. He dropped them into a tiny puddle behind the rocks, where he could eat them later.
One day the crab said, “Take me next!” The heron thought, “A crab will make a nice change.” He let the crab hold on to his long neck, and up they flew.
From high in the sky the crab looked down. He saw the hill, but he saw no lake. There was only a tiny puddle crowded with frightened fish. “You tricked us!” cried the crab, and he held the heron’s neck tight with his strong claws.
“Ow! Let go!” squawked the heron. “Only if you take every fish back home,” said the crab. So the heron carried them all back to the pond, one by one. Then he flew far away and never returned. And the rain came after all.
A note for grown-ups: in the traditional telling the crab deals with the heron far more firmly. We keep it gentle here, so every fish goes home and the heron simply flies away.
What is the moral?
Don’t believe everything you hear. Check for yourself, and be brave enough to speak up.
Look for yourself
The fish believed the heron because he sounded so sure. The crab looked down with his own eyes, and the truth was plain to see.
Speak up
The crab did not stay quiet. He said “You tricked us!” and made things right.
Meet the characters
The old heron
He is hungry and crafty. Instead of asking for help, he uses a scary story to get what he wants.
The crab
The crab is small but sharp-eyed and brave. He thinks of the other fish first.
The fish
They are trusting and afraid. Their fear makes it easy for them to believe the heron.
Questions to ask, by age
For ages five and six
- Why was the heron always hungry?
- What did the crab see from up in the sky?
- How did the story end for the fish?
For ages seven to nine
- Why did the fish believe the heron so quickly?
- What could the fish have done to check his story?
- Have you ever heard something that turned out not to be true? What did you do?
Where does the story come from?
The heron and the crab is one of the fables in the Panchatantra, an ancient Indian collection of animal stories traditionally credited to Vishnu Sharma. The details change from teller to teller, and many versions end more sternly than ours.
More to explore on Rangooo
See this tale with pictures and a colouring page, browse the Panchatantra stories, try the story picker or the moral quiz, read the Crows and the Snake and Blue Jackal guides, or learn how to teach kids the Panchatantra.
Questions
What is the moral of the Heron and the Crab story?
Do not believe everything you hear. Check for yourself, and be brave enough to speak up when something is wrong.
Is the Heron and the Crab a Panchatantra story?
Yes. It is one of the animal fables of the Panchatantra, the ancient Indian collection traditionally credited to Vishnu Sharma. Tellers differ on the details.
How did the crab find out the heron’s trick?
When the heron carried him up into the sky, the crab looked down and saw no lake at all, only a tiny puddle crowded with frightened fish.
Does the story end happily for children?
In our gentle version, yes. The crab makes the heron carry every fish back to the pond, the heron flies away for good and the rain comes after all.
This is our own retelling of a traditional tale, written for young children. Versions differ from teller to teller. If you spot a mistake, please tell us and we will fix it.